BigCommerce vs Gumroad: Best Platform for Selling Digital Products: Simple Storefront or Full-Scale Ecommerce?

When it comes to selling digital products, choosing the right platform can significantly impact your business's success. Leaders in this space are often torn between opting for BigCommerce and Gumroad. Each of these platforms offers unique features designed to sell digital products, but they cater to different business needs and goals. As Martin Dejnicki, technology leader and blogger at Deploi.ca, my goal today is to bring clarity to your decision-making process by comparing these two platforms through the lens of our Storybrand framework, focusing on applicability, features, ease of use, scalability, and customer support.

Understanding What Each Platform Offers

BigCommerce: A Full-Scale Ecommerce Solution

BigCommerce is a robust ecommerce platform designed to handle large-scale, complex online stores. It offers an array of features that empower businesses to manage a diverse product portfolio, including digital products. From customizable themes to comprehensive SEO tools and multi-channel selling capabilities, BigCommerce is built to scale and adapt to growing business needs.

Gumroad: The Simple Storefront for Creators

Gumroad, on the other hand, is a specialized platform tailored for creators looking to sell digital products simply and efficiently. Whether you're a writer, artist, software developer, or online educator, Gumroad’s streamlined interface makes it easy to upload and sell digital goods. It isn’t as feature-rich as BigCommerce, but it excels in its simplicity and ease of use, offering a straightforward path from product creation to sale.

Usability and Onboarding

BigCommerce: A Learning Curve with Greater Control

BigCommerce offers a wealth of customization options which can be enticing for tech-savvy business owners. However, the sheer number of features can be overwhelming. The onboarding process includes setting up product categories, configuring SEO, and integrating with various third-party services. While this platform provides extensive documentation and customer support to guide you through setup, a level of technical proficiency is beneficial for maximizing its potential.

Gumroad: User-Friendly Simplicity

Gumroad shines in its simplicity. The onboarding process is incredibly straightforward: you create an account, upload your digital product, set a price, and hit publish. It's designed for creators who want to focus on their craft rather than getting bogged down by technical details. This ease of use makes Gumroad an ideal choice for those who want to get started quickly without a steep learning curve.

Features and Flexibility

BigCommerce: A Feature-Rich Powerhouse

BigCommerce excels with its extensive range of features:

• Customizable Themes: Choose from various themes and customize them to match your brand identity.
• SEO Tools: Comprehensive SEO settings help improve your search engine ranking.
• Multi-Channel Selling: Integrate with platforms like Amazon, eBay, and social media channels.
• Advanced Analytics: Gain insights into sales performance and customer behavior.
• Abandoned Cart Recovery: Automated emails to recover lost sales.

These features make BigCommerce not just a store, but a powerful ecommerce ecosystem capable of scaling and adapting as your business grows.

Gumroad: Focusing on Core Competencies

While not as feature-rich, Gumroad provides everything needed to sell digital products:

• Simple Product Upload: Quickly upload digital files, set prices, and start selling.
• Easy Payment Processing: Supports multiple currencies and payment methods.
• Customer List Management: Collect emails and send updates directly from Gumroad's interface.
• Drip Content: Schedule content to be delivered over a period of time.
• Analytics: Basic analytics to track sales and customer interactions.

Gumroad’s straightforward features are perfect for individual creators and small businesses that don't require the extensive functionalities of a full-scale ecommerce platform.

Scalability and Growth

BigCommerce: Built to Grow with Your Business

A key strength of BigCommerce is its scalability. Whether you're just starting out or running an established business, BigCommerce can grow with you:

• Flexible Pricing Plans: Choose a plan that matches your current stage and upgrade as you grow.
• App Marketplace: Integrate additional tools and services to expand functionality.
• Unlimited Products: Sell an unlimited number of digital products without any performance issues.
• Global Reach: Handle multiple currencies and languages to cater to an international audience.

These capabilities make BigCommerce an ideal choice for businesses planning to scale and potentially expand into different markets or product lines.

Gumroad: Simplicity that Scales

While Gumroad isn’t as scalable as BigCommerce when it comes to large, diverse product portfolios, it’s perfectly capable of growing with solo entrepreneurs or small shops:

• No Limits on Product Listings: Sell unlimited digital products without worrying about additional fees.
• Simple Pricing: A straightforward pricing model based on a small percentage of sales means no hidden costs as you grow.
• Community Features: As your brand grows, Gumroad's follower feature allows you to build a community around your products.

For creators who want to scale their digital goods business without complicating their workflow, Gumroad offers a simple, efficient solution.

Customer Support and Community

BigCommerce: Comprehensive Support

BigCommerce provides a wide array of support options:

• 24/7 Support: Access to customer support via phone, email, and live chat.
• Resource Library: Extensive documentation, webinars, and community forums.
• Dedicated Account Managers: Higher-tier plans offer dedicated support for personalized assistance.

The robust support infrastructure ensures that businesses, regardless of size, receive timely and effective assistance.

Gumroad: Community-Driven Assistance

Gumroad's support is more community-focused:

• Email Support: Receive timely help via email.
• Active Community: Join forums and community groups to share experiences and get advice.
• Educational Content: Access blog posts, tutorials, and webinars to learn more about maximizing Gumroad's tools.

While Gumroad’s support isn't as extensive as BigCommerce’s, its strong community and educational resources provide ample assistance for most creators' needs.

Making the Choice: Which Platform is Right for You?

Choosing between BigCommerce and Gumroad ultimately depends on your specific needs and business goals.

• Choose BigCommerce if: You’re running a large-scale, complex digital store and need a feature-rich, scalable platform. It’s ideal for businesses looking to integrate various sales channels, extensive SEO tools, and advanced analytics.

• Choose Gumroad if: You're a creator or a small business seeking a simple, straightforward way to sell digital products. Its ease of use, lack of a steep learning curve, and community-driven support make it perfect for those who prefer not to get entangled with overly complex systems.

At Deploi.ca, we understand the importance of choosing the right technology for your business. By understanding the strengths and limitations of each platform, you can make a more informed decision that aligns with your goals, ensuring your digital products reach their full potential. Contact us today to explore how we can support your journey to digital success.