Volusion vs Big Cartel: Full-Featured Ecommerce or Streamlined Artist Marketplace?

blog-image

Navigating the ecommerce landscape can be overwhelming, especially with the myriad of platforms available to cater to diverse business needs. Today, we dive deep into two distinctive platforms: Volusion and Big Cartel. Each brings its unique strengths and caters to particular markets, but how do you determine which is the right fit for your business? Let's unravel the details, so you can make an informed decision.

The Essence of Volusion

Volusion has been a longstanding player in the ecommerce arena. Built to scale with businesses from startup phase to enterprise-level operations, Volusion offers a comprehensive suite of features aimed at providing a full-featured ecommerce experience.

Robust Feature Set

Volusion stands out for its extensive capabilities. It offers built-in SEO features, marketing tools, inventory management, and a plethora of themes. More critically, it supports a wide variety of product options and variations, making it ideal for businesses that offer a diverse and complex product line.

Key Features:
  • Professional Templates and Themes: Volusion supports a myriad of customizable templates, allowing brands to create a unique online presence that aligns with their identity.
  • SEO and Marketing Tools: Bolster your online visibility with Volusion’s built-in tools for creating meta tags, conducting A/B testing, and crafting email campaigns.
  • Comprehensive Analytics: Gain valuable insights through custom reports and dashboards that help track performance and fine-tune strategies.
  • Payment Integration and Security: Secure transactions with multiple payment gateways and robust security protocols compliant with PCI.

Flexibility and Scalability

Businesses that start small but aim to grow will find Volusion’s scalability appealing. It accommodates expansive product catalogs and high-traffic operations without compromising performance. This scalability is essential for businesses anticipating rapid growth or those already operating at a high scale needing a reliable backbone.

Big Cartel: The Artist-Friendly Solution

On the other side of the spectrum, we have Big Cartel, a niche platform designed with artists, photographers, and small makers in mind. If simplicity and ease-of-use are what you seek, Big Cartel’s streamlined, user-friendly approach might be the solution.

A Seamless Onboarding Experience

Big Cartel shines in its simplicity. Setting up a store can be done in minutes, making it incredibly friendly for those new to ecommerce or unwilling to deal with complex configurations. This minimalist platform focuses on getting artists and creators online quickly, without the need for a technical background.

Key Features:
  • User-Focused Design: Big Cartel’s interface is designed to be easily navigable, allowing creators to focus more on their art and less on store maintenance.
  • Cost-Effective Plans: Affordable pricing tiers, including a free plan that supports up to 5 products, make Big Cartel attractive for budding entrepreneurs and hobbyists.
  • Streamlined Product Management: Managing products, tracking orders, and running promotions are straightforward tasks, reducing the cognitive load on users.
  • Customizable Themes: While not as extensive as Volusion, Big Cartel offers clean, simple themes that can be customized to reflect an artist’s vision.

Made for the Niche

Big Cartel is not just an ecommerce platform; it’s a community for creators. By focusing on this niche market, it empowers artists to monetize their craft without overwhelming them with features better suited for larger operations.

Battle of Approaches: Full-Featured vs Streamlined

Understanding which platform suits your needs requires examining your business’s objectives and resources. Are you an artist looking for a hassle-free way to sell your creations, or are you managing a large product catalog with global ambitions?

Customization and Control

Volusion offers ample customization through its professional templates and robust backend customization options. For businesses needing detailed control over their site’s look and functionality, Volusion delivers the necessary tools.

In contrast, Big Cartel’s themes are more straightforward but allow for basic CSS and HTML tweaks. This makes Big Cartel perfect for those who need quick, clean, and effective websites without diving deep into custom code.

Marketing and SEO

With Volusion, you gain more advanced marketing capabilities. The built-in SEO tools and marketing functionalities like email campaigns and social media integrations are crucial for businesses aiming to drive high traffic and conversion rates.

Big Cartel, however, keeps it lean. While it does offer basic SEO elements like title tags and simple social media links, it falls short of providing extensive marketing automation tools. Therefore, if your growth strategy heavily leans on digital marketing, Volusion might be the more competent choice.

Ease of Use vs Feature-Richness

Big Cartel's intuitive interface means that virtually anyone can set up an online store without technical know-how. However, this simplicity comes at the expense of advanced features.

Volusion, while straightforward enough for someone with a basic understanding of ecommerce, does have a steeper learning curve due to its multitude of features. For users willing to invest time in mastering the platform, the rewards are considerable.

Cost Effectiveness

Budget can often be the deciding factor. Big Cartel’s pricing structure is highly attractive for individual artists and startups, with a free plan and affordable paid tiers. Volusion, on the other hand, offers more advanced features at a higher cost, which may be justified for businesses expecting significant revenue and growth.

Making the Decision

Choosing between Volusion and Big Cartel ultimately depends on your business model and growth aspirations. If you're an artist or a small creator seeking a simple, affordable way to bring your work to the market, Big Cartel is likely your best bet. Its ease of use and focus on individual creators make it a wonderful tool for turning passion into profit.

However, if you're managing a larger operation with ambitions for scale, high traffic, and complex product management needs, Volusion provides the depth, flexibility, and scalability needed to support your growth. The advanced marketing tools, extensive customization options, and robust analytics features will better serve a business looking to expand its reach and optimize its operations.

At Deploi, we understand that the right technology selection is pivotal to your success. Should you need further guidance or want to discuss your options in greater detail, reach out to us. We're passionate about helping you build a digital solution that aligns perfectly with your vision and goals. Let's take your business to the next level together.

Martin Dejnicki

Martin is the Director of Engineering & Enterprise SEO at Deploi, with over 25 years of experience driving measurable growth for enterprises. Since launching his first website at 16, he has empowered industry leaders like Walmart, IBM, Rogers, and TD Securities through cutting-edge digital strategies that deliver real results. At Deploi, Martin leads a high-performing team, passionately creating game-changing solutions and spearheading innovative projects, including a groundbreaking algorithmic trading platform and a ChatGPT-driven CMS. His commitment to excellence ensures that every strategy transforms challenges into opportunities for success.